Sustainable Development as Cargo Cult: Strange Tales of Scale Making from Melanesia and Beyond

Simple item page
dc.contributor.authorGolub, Alex
dc.date.accessioned2010-06-17T20:45:10Z
dc.date.available2010-06-17T20:45:10Z
dc.date.issued2007-12
dc.description106th American Anthropological Association Annual Meeting
dc.descriptionWashington, DC
dc.descriptionNovember 28 - December 2, 2007
dc.descriptionNon-refereed
dc.descriptionFor AAA session "Arenas, Audiences and Knowledge: Regimes of Credibility in Environmental Politics," 11/30/2007
dc.description.abstractWhile the hyper-exotic discourse of 'cargo cult' continues to draw attention in popular media representations of Melanesia, many anthropologists have noted that the movements thus labeled represent a more general Melanesian form of sociality which emphasizes the creation of social unity as a means of obtaining wealth. This paper contrasts 'Cargo Cults' with corporate and environmentalist discourses of sustainable development, which seeks to unite stakeholders in a state of social unity in order to obtain wealth and the good life. In both cases the success of desired change at the macro-level depends on micro-level subjects taking "ownership" of the proposed changes to social life. The difference is that some 'cargo cults' such as the Christian Fellowship Church in the Solomons and the John Frum movement in Vanuatu have created social orders which have endured for decades while the vast majority of 'development' projects in Melanesia have failed. This paper asks: how and why do white discourses render credible, believable, and intelligible discourses of 'sustainable development' 'fighting corruption' and 'capacity building' while the macro-level aspirations of grassroots aspirations slip constantly back into the derogatory and exoticizing label of 'cargo cult'? Can our sense of an unproblematic notion of 'credibility' emerge unscathed in a world where Melanesian enthusiasm for organizations like 'integrated conservation and development areas' is now continuous with white dreams of reforming Melanesian social orders in the name of the environment?
dc.identifier.citationGolub, Alex. 2007. Sustainable Development as Cargo Cult: Strange Tales of Scale Making from Melanesia and Beyond. 106th American Anthropological Association Annual Meeting.
dc.identifier.otherFormer Mana'o EPrint ID92
dc.identifier.urihttp://hdl.handle.net/10524/1596
dc.subjectMelanesia
dc.subjectPorgera
dc.subjectPapua New Guinea
dc.subjectcargo cults
dc.subjectdevelopment
dc.subjectenvironmental politics
dc.subjectfeasibility
dc.subjectsubjectivity
dc.subjectagency
dc.subjectsocial organization
dc.subject.lcshEthnology
dc.subject.lcshPapua New Guinea
dc.titleSustainable Development as Cargo Cult: Strange Tales of Scale Making from Melanesia and Beyond
dc.typeConference_item

Files

Original bundle
Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
No Thumbnail Available
Name:
AAA_07_credibility_paper.pdf
Size:
99.05 KB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format
Download

Collections

Mana'o - Asia-Pacific Region Collection